The Construction ADR Toolbox

Resources for Construction Lawyers and ADR Professionals

·

Shortening Time to File Claim Backfires: Court Voids Arbitration Clause

Shortening the time frame to file an arbitration claim may be tempting to some drafters. Creating a narrow window for such claims seems beneficial since it may reduce the number of claims. However, drafters should be cautious since such provisions may backfire. Some courts void the entire arbitration clause where a shortened filing time violates a statute or public policy.

Beware of State Statutes Against Shortening Time Limits

Several states have specific statutes prohibiting contracts from shortening the statutory limitations period.[i] Courts in states lacking specific statutes may refuse to enforce shortened time limits if they are unreasonable.[ii] Some courts find arbitration clauses with unreasonable limitations are unconscionable and unenforceable as violating public policy. This is especially true where the parties have unequal bargaining power, such as in adhesion contracts. Courts scrutinize contract provisions particularly in “take it or leave it” situations where one party dictates the terms with no negotiation.

Homeowner Construction Contract Has Shortened Time for Claims

In Huskins v. Mungo Homes, LLC[iii] the homebuyers sued the homebuilder for various claims.   The trial court granted the homebuilder’s motion to compel arbitration. The homebuyers appealed, asserting the arbitration clause was unconscionable and unenforceable. The clause required arbitration demands be made within ninety days after the claim arose, contrary to SC Code Ann. §15-3-140, which renders such contract clauses void and unenforceable.

Appellate Court Severs Clause, Compels Arbitration 

The appellate court agreed that the clause shortening the time for claims was unconscionable and unenforceable but found that it could be severed from the rest of the contract. Therefore, the court affirmed the order compelling arbitration.

SC Supreme Court Voids Entire Arbitration Clause

The S.C. Supreme Court reversed, noting that there was no “severability” clause in the contract.  There was no other indication that the parties intended the arbitration clause to stand if part of it was found unenforceable. While noting that courts often sever illegal portions of contracts and enforce the remainder, here the S.C. Supreme Court found the contract’s adhesive nature[iv] and “Mungo’s manipulative skirting of S.C. public policy” weighed heavily against severance.

Mungo Made Its Choice and Now It Is Stuck with It         

Declining to sever the illegal provision and salvage the arbitration clause, the S.C. Supreme Court stated:

 Mungo insisted upon an adhesion contract so its terms could not be varied and would stick. Mungo is stuck with its choice. Were we to hold otherwise, parties who impose standard form adhesion contracts on weaker parties would have no downside to throwing in blatantly illegal terms betting they will go unchallenged or, at worst, that courts will throw them out and enforce the rest. 

The S.C. Supreme Court held the entire arbitration clause unenforceable and reversed the order compelling arbitration.

SCOTUS Declines Review

Mungo filed a petition for certiorari review in the U.S. Supreme Court, presenting the question as, “Whether the South Carolina Supreme Court applied a severability rule that disfavors arbitration in this case.”  The Supreme Court denied the petition.

Takeaways

  • When drafting (or editing) an arbitration clause, counsel should be cautious regarding shortening the time for arbitration claims (and similar limitations). A combination of limitations may lead a court to find a clause unconscionable and unenforceable.
  • Including a severability clause in the contract can prevent the problem found in Huskins v. Mungo Homes.

[i][i] E.g. Ala. Code §6-2-15; Fla. Stat. §95.03; Idaho Code §29-110; Mo. Rev. Stat. §431.030; Mont. Code Ann. §29.2-708; S.C. Code Ann. §15-3-140; S.D. Cod. Law 53-9-6; Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code §16.070; 8 Vt. Stat. Ann. §3663

[ii]Ramirez v. Charter Communications, Inc., 551 P.3d 520 (CA 2024) https://law.justia.com/cases/california/supreme-court/2024/s273802.html

[iii] 910 S.E.2d 474 (SC 2024), cert. den. 444 S.Ct. 592 (2025) https://law.justia.com/cases/south-carolina/supreme-court/2024/28245.html

[iv] Mungo conceded the contract was one of adhesion that was presented on a “take it or leave it” basis.